My College Application Essay;teacher Hated It But I Like It,thanks!!
egarcia162
I happened across The Virtue of Selfishness when I was in the ninth grade; it was buried under a stack of tattered old journals in my older sister's room. I had snuck in there to snoop for issues of Cosmos, which my mother insisted she hide from me; possessed with curiosity, I took that as a challenge. But The Virtue of Selfishness, with its navy cover and dull-gold writing stopped me. Its manila library checkout pocket was stamped THOMAS CRANE LIBRARY, the library my sister often visited. I did not stop to wonder why she would have taken the strange, plain looking book; first publish in 1964, about ethics. Figuring that if she had swiped it, it must be juicy. I dashed into my room, ran over to my bed, slid under the covers, and commenced a non-stop reading session of ecstasy and enlightenment.

That was 4 years ago. After all this time, its dog-eared pages, kept together with some duck tape and a trusty binder clip remain on my bedside table. I pick it up about twice a year, with the intention to leaf through and find a favorite quote. Yet end up as engaged as the first time I read it; seemingly radical concepts of rational selfishness, living a productive life, and doing so with pleasure, passion, and pride still hook me.

At thirteen, I was inspired by Ayn Rand's ideas, which to me were revolutionary. It was the beginning of freshman year, and these new revelations of feminism and self-empowerment audaciously clashed with the traditional expectations I had always known. I now knew that I longed for something different for myself, unsure but armed with certain suspicions about what it might entail. Rand had logically and virtually undeniably argued her points. She defied convention, mystics, and traditional values (the book isn't called The Virtue of Kindness after all). The traditional framework and history of the subject at hand, made her philosophy radical. I wanted to be that fearlessly progressive, that confident of my convictions, that willing to base my life on my own logic and values. It was Ayn Rand I thought of at 15 when my father first insisted I try to be a pharmacist, because I would not make it in business. It was Ayn Rand I thought of when I quit my part-time job to intern for an advertising agency in Boston.

But last summer, during my most recent reading of The Virtue of Selfishness I was shocked by an epiphany of sorts. Although Ayn Rand, had meant what she said, and said what she meant in her book, I had not really understood the message. As a thirteen-year-old I had read and thought of each word as literal truth and gospel; it had never occurred to me to question that assumption. But what I had really accepted was my own interpretation of her message, which to be completely honest was a foolish and selfish interpretation, and not the "good selfish" Rand promoted.

Using her words as justification, I allowed myself to wallow in foolish behavior, such as procrastination. Passing off such behavior as just “being true to myself”, I ended up in less than ideal situations at Fontbonne Academy. Which was where, for the first time ever, I have been challenged with school work because of a strict and advanced curriculum. So despite having my SAT scores place me among the highest of the senior class, my GPA did relatively nothing to reflect this ranking. Prior to this I had been adored and cherished as an intelligent and artistic child. So the way I worked below my potential frustrated my peers, teachers, and family, and eventually myself.

I realized that while congratulating myself and to taking pride in my intelligence, bravery and reason when things were going well, and the pressures of graduation and college were not upon me was easy. The challenge remained to trust in myself, my work, my studies, my family, and my gut, when under the most difficult of situations. I had believed that solely being completely selfishly rational and living on my own terms, I would be protected from bad luck, pain, mistakes and failure. Clearly, I had missed the point of the book. Those things are unavoidable, and in actuality are what constitute a life wholly and passionately lived.

While Rand once said that "happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one's values", she left what those values specifically are mostly up for debate. Armed with an understanding of this, and what my values are now I am better prepared to enter the adult world, and reach that state of happiness. With the necessary beginnings of a solid foundation to live up to my high aspirations I am confident that this is possible. As a child, the almost defiant passion to stand up for what I thought, was evident as I was received the "Most likely to become a lawyer" award. As a young woman that passion is still evident, simply refined and driven by valid values that I now cherish and practice. However I require further enlightenment, knowledge, and sophistication to solidify and utilize to hopefully work my way to graduating with a master’s degree. However I trust that ultimately guiding me towards my aspirations will be my principles and passion. I know that I am an intelligent individual, with the uncanny skill of being incredibly perceptive and thinking logically. I believe that as I gain experience and knowledge I will reach my true potential and learning in itself will be fruitfully enjoyable.











P.S. Copy & Pasting took away the formatting its correctly formatted when in word.

<Keywords...>

Comments

RobertXX
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Nov 3rd, 2009

From the top.

"Snuck" isn't a word that is normally used in formal writing. While not entirely improper, it's not an really an appropriate choice of wording.

Way too many uses of a semi-colon. Entire treatises have been written without the use of one, you used 5. In most cases, it's more appropriate to end the sentence and begin a new one.

Your sentence structure is poor. People too often use commas because they feel if they were "speaking the words", they would pause. In formal writing, a comma is not necessarily used to denote a pause, but rather a "shift" of thoughts, ideas or a "list". Some of your sentences combine disparate thoughts, ideas and observations, and are difficult to follow. Many of your sentences would be considered "run on" sentences, that should be split.

The word "its" in your p.s. is incorrect, it should be "it's".

Substantively I'd give you an A, technically a C-.
November,03 2009

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
RobertXX
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Nov 3rd, 2009
Ric3189

If you're going to comment on someone else's use of proper English, you should be more careful. In your first sentence, the word "need" should be "needs".

In your 2nd sentence, the word "there" should be capitalized and the word "is" should be replaced with the plural, "are". In your reference to "a few run-ons", you improperly used the plural. The word "need" should be plural, not singular.

You used 25 words and had 5 errors. I'd give you D-, all around !
November,03 2009

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
RobertXX
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Nov 3rd, 2009
This place is mind boggling!

Hey Naseera, you have a nerve! You have 2 errors in your first 2 sentences !

"I would have to tell you in the first paragraph"? What sort of English is that?

"... has and error"? Perhaps you meant "an" error?

"If you sending this"? Perhaps you meant: "if you ARE sending this"?

"Proofreading" is one word.

"Give the ... to your teacher for their CRITICS"? Did you mean "criticisms"?

Including punctuation (which you basically ignored), I counted at least 7 errors in your 9 "sentences". You really shouldn't be commenting on someone else's errors.
November,04 2009

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
RobertXX
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Nov 3rd, 2009
I only had about 20 minutes to re-write this and did NOT proofread it, nor always understand your intent. Take it for what it's worth.

I discovered “The Virtue of Selfishness”, when I was in the ninth grade. I found it in my older sister’s room, buried under a stack of old, tattered journals.

My mother insisted my sister hide her issues of Cosmopolitan from me, lest I become too cosmopolitan at my young age. Possessed by curiosity, the challenge was irresistible! During one of my snooping expeditions, I was beguiled by my discovery of the striking navy cover and dull gold printing of Ayn Rand’s classic.

Noticing the manila library checkout pocket embossed “Thomas Crane Library”, made me wonder why my sister would have opted to stash this particular book, hidden away under her journals. A book on ethics? From 1964? It must be damn juicy, to warrant such attention! I dashed back to my room, slid under the covers of my bed and began a journey of ecstasy and enlightenment.

That was 4 years ago. Now the dog-eared pages are barely kept together, binded with duct tape. A black blinder clip, holds the package together and safe, on my bedside table. A few times a year, I reach to thumb through it to find a favorite quote, but instead end up engaged and enthralled, all over again. I’m still enraptured by the seemingly radical concepts of rational selfishness, living a productive life, and doing so, with pleasure, passion and pride.

At thirteen, I was inspired by Ayn Rand's ideas, which seemed so revolutionary to me. It was the beginning of my freshman year, and these revelations of feminism and self-empowerment, audaciously clashed with my traditional expectations. I know knew I wanted and needed some more and different for myself. I was unsure, confused and conflicted, but armed with certain suspicions about my challenge.

Rand logically and convincingly argued her points. She defied convention, mystics, and traditional values (the book isn't called The Virtue of Kindness after all). The traditional framework and history of the subject at hand, made her philosophy radical. I myself wanted to be that fearlessly progressive. I longed to possess such confidence in my convictions, willing to base my life on my own logic and values.

It was Ayn Rand I thought of at 15, when my father first insisted I should be a pharmacist, because I wouldn’t make it in business. It was Ayn Rand I thought of when I quit my part-time job, to intern for an advertising agency in Boston.

Then last summer, during my last reading of The Virtue of Selfishness, I was shocked by an epiphany of sorts. Although Ayn Rand had meant what she said, and said what she meant, I had misunderstood her message. As a thirteen year-old, I took each word at face value, believing each of her thoughts, to be the literal truth and gospel. Until now, I had never questioned my assumptions.

I finally realized, I had really only accepted my own interpretation of her message. In retrospect, that was a foolish and selfish interpretation and certainly not the "good selfish" Rand promoted.

Using her words as my justification, I allowed myself to wallow in nonproductive behavior, such as procrastination and disinterest. Justifying such behavior as merely “being true to myself”, I found myself lowering my personal expectations.

When I enrolled at Fontbonne Academy, for the first time in my life, I was actually challenged and stimulated. The advanced curriculum and expectations of the staff, awoke me from my malaise. I suddenly realized, despite having some of the highest SAT scores in my class, my grades weren’t commensurate with my abilities. I had gone from being an “intelligent and artistic child”, to an under-performer. I was disappointing my family, my peers, my teachers and most of all, myself.


I realized that self-indulgence was easy, until the pressures of graduation and college raised their formidable presence.

The challenge remained to trust in myself, my work, my studies, my family, and my gut, when under the most strain. I had believed that being totally and selfishly rational and living on my own terms, I would be protected from bad luck, pain, mistakes and failure. Clearly, I had missed the point of Rand’s book. Those things are unavoidable, and in reality, are what constitute a life wholly and passionately lived.

While Rand once said that "happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one's values", she left what those specific values are, up for debate.

Armed with a better understanding of my own expectations of myself and of my personal values,I’m better prepared to take the next step toward adulthood and strive toward my individual happiness.

With the requisite beginnings of a solid foundation, I’m confident I’m ready to live up to my high aspirations and confident of achieving my goals.

As a child, the almost defiant passion to stand up for my beliefs, was evident when my 7th grade class voted me the, "Most likely to become a lawyer" award. As a young woman, that passion is still evident, however refined and substantiated by the quality values I now cherish and practice.

All the challenges are not yet met. Further enlightenment, knowledge, and sophistication is needed, to meet my goal of graduating with a Master’s Degree and moving into the business world.

However I now know my principles and passion will guide me as I strive to meet my personal aspirations. I’m intelligent, perceptive and sometimes logical to a fault. I’m confident that as I gain knowledge, experience and seasoning, I’ll reach my ultimate potential.
November,04 2009

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
RobertXX
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Nov 3rd, 2009
Damn!

I wish I had taken the time to proofread my edits. I used too many commas and have a few other errors. Oh well, I think the overall construction is better and in spite of not quite understanding your intent, I think I made your words more compelling.
November,04 2009

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
RobertXX
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Nov 3rd, 2009
OK, I had a few more minutes to give it a quick proofread. How's this?

I only had about 20 minutes to rewrite this and did NOT proofread it, nor always understand your intent. Take it for what it's worth.

During the ninth grade, I discovered “The Virtue of Selfishness”. I found it in my older sister’s room, buried under a stack of old, tattered journals.

My mother insisted my sister hide her issues of Cosmopolitan from me, lest I become too cosmopolitan at my tender age. Possessed by curiosity, the challenge was irresistible. During one of my snooping expeditions, I was beguiled by my discovery of the striking navy cover and dull gold printing of Ayn Rand’s classic.

Noticing the manila library checkout pocket embossed “Thomas Crane Library”, made me wonder why my sister would have opted to surreptitiously stash this particular book, hidden away under her journals. A book on ethics? From 1964? It must be damn juicy to warrant such attention! I dashed back to my room, slid under the covers of my bed and began a journey of ecstasy and enlightenment.

Four years later, the dog-eared pages are barely kept together, binded with duct tape. A black blinder clip holds the package together and safe, on my bedside table. A few times a year, I reach to thumb through it to find a favorite quote, but instead I end up engaged and enthralled, all over again. I’m still enraptured by the seemingly radical concepts of rational selfishness, living a productive life, and doing so with pleasure, passion and pride.

At thirteen I was inspired by Ayn Rand's ideas, which seemed revolutionary to me. It was the beginning of my freshman year, and these revelations of feminism and self-empowerment, audaciously clashed with my traditional expectations. I now knew I wanted and needed something more and different for myself. I was unsure, confused and conflicted, but armed with certain suspicions about my challenge.

Rand logically and convincingly argued her points. She defied convention, mystics, and traditional values (the book isn't called The Virtue of Kindness after all). The traditional parameters and history of the subject at hand, made her philosophy radical. I myself wanted to be that fearlessly progressive. I longed to possess such confidence in my convictions, willing to base my life on my own logic and values.

It was Ayn Rand I thought of at 15, when my father first insisted I should be a pharmacist, because I wouldn’t make it in business. It was Ayn Rand I thought of when I quit my part-time job, to intern for an advertising agency in Boston.

Then last summer, during my latest reading of The Virtue of Selfishness, I was shocked by an epiphany of sorts. Although Ayn Rand had meant what she said, and said what she meant, I had misunderstood her message. As a thirteen year-old, I took each word at face value, believing each of her thoughts to be the literal truth and gospel. Until then, I had never questioned my assumptions.

I finally realized, I had really only accepted my own interpretation of her message. In retrospect, that was a foolish and selfish interpretation and certainly not the "good selfish" Rand promoted.

Using her words as my justification, I had allowed myself to wallow in nonproductive behavior, such as procrastination and disinterest. I justified such behavior as merely “being true to myself”, and found myself lowering my personal expectations.

When I enrolled at Fontbonne Academy, for the first time in my life, I was actually challenged and stimulated. The advanced curriculum and expectations of the staff, awoke me from my malaise. I suddenly realized, despite having some of the highest SAT scores in my class, my grades weren’t commensurate with my abilities. I had gone from being an “intelligent and artistic child”, to an under-performer. I was disappointing my family, my peers, my teachers and most of all, myself.

I realized that self-indulgence was easy, and then the pressures of graduation and college raised their formidable presence.

The challenge remained to trust in myself, my work, my studies, my family, and my gut, when under the most strain. I had believed that being totally and selfishly rational and living on my own terms, I would be protected from bad luck, pain, mistakes and failure. Clearly I had missed the point of Rand’s book. Those things are unavoidable, and in reality, are what constitute a life wholly and passionately lived.

While Rand once said that "happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one's values", she left what those specific values are, up for debate. Armed with a better understanding of my own expectations for myself and of my personal values, I’m better prepared to take the next step toward adulthood and strive toward my individual happiness and fulfillment.

With the requisite beginnings of a solid foundation, I’m confident I’m ready to live up to my lofty aspirations and confident of achieving my goals.

As a child, the almost defiant passion to stand up for my beliefs, was evident when my 7th grade class voted me the "Most likely to become a lawyer" award. As a young woman, that passion is still evident, however refined and substantiated by the quality values I now cherish and practice.

All the challenges are not yet met. Further enlightenment, knowledge, and sophistication is needed, to meet my goal of graduating with a Master’s Degree and moving into the business world.
November,05 2009

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
AbhiSingh
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Jan 6th, 2010
Not a whole lot I can add to the above comments/rewrites. It's a good essay, just the syntax is a bit on the flimsy side.
January,06 2010

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
Myartist13
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Jan 12th, 2010
With all of the other "proof-reads" i will not add anything. However, I agree with the comment above.
January,12 2010

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
Author:
Egarcia162
+2
Reputation Points

Member Since
Oct 21st, 2009
Hi so this was my essay and despite the bad grades I found your comments to be very helpful, so thank you for taking the time to comment.

BTW I thought that maybe you folks shouldn't argue with each other over little things like I saw a few people doing. I think that it is great that we are all on this site helping each other out and sometimes we can notice mistakes in other people's writings instead of our own. Plus when we are commenting on a paper here, I don't really think we proofread it and make it super formal.

Anyways Thanks a lot!

& yes I'm sure I have abunch of mistakes in this comment. ohwell, im learning to be a better writer :)
January,14 2010

ML2000
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Jan 22nd, 2010
Everyone has already said it...Proofread!!! Other than that it was pretty good!!
January,22 2010

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
Kprox
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Jan 31st, 2010
I think there were a few problems with your noun-verb agreements like when need should have been needs, but other that that I though it was pretty decent, a little rough, but a little revision would make it a pretty good paper
January,31 2010

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: 0
Ric3189
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Nov 3rd, 2009
Change the word snuck. Sentence structure need stronger words to support it. there is a few run-ons sentences and need a period or change the sentence.
November,03 2009

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: -1
Naseera
0
Reputation Points

Member Since
Aug 19th, 2009
I would have to tell you in the first paragraph there are at least 3 visible errors. The very first word in the essay has and error. Instead of "it happened" you wrote "I happened". I can tell you it is a turn off to see an error as soon as you start reading an essay. If you sending this to a college as an essay for entry you should consider first proof reading it yourself then having at least 2 family or friends proof read it. Then after they have done that for you submit it to a place like this site. Then use these critics to make changes. Lastly give the final draft to your teacher for their critics.

I am sorry but I will have to give this a D.
November,04 2009

Rate Comment:
Comment Rating: -1
Log In to post a comment.
egarcia162
Comments Posted:
7

Essays Posted:
2

Reputation Points:
+2

Member Since
October, 21st 2009

Recent Activity
September, 5th 2010

About egarcia162




EssayJudge.com has a Zero Tolerance for Plagiarism!
Please send questions, comments or site feedback to Admin@EssayJudge.com
Site Map